Ethernet Magnetics: Discrete Or Integrated? | Engineers' Insight | Avnet Abacus

Display portlet menu

Ethernet Magnetics: Discrete Or Integrated? | Engineers' Insight | Avnet Abacus

Display portlet menu

Ethernet magnetics – Discrete or integrated?

Adam Chidley Photo

If you’re adding wired Ethernet to a design, you will of course have to consider magnetics.

If you’re adding wired Ethernet to a design, you will of course have to consider magnetics. All Ethernet enabled equipment has to include magnetics as the Ethernet specification for 10/100/1000BASE-T networks requires a certain level of galvanic isolation from the cable. 1:1 Transformers are usually used to meet this requirement as they also provide any required DC biasing (say when the nodes are powered from different sources, which may result in a ground offset between the transmitting and receiving equipment).  Transformers also provide common mode rejection which is useful for noise attenuation between the PHY device (transceiver IC) and the physical medium (cable). 

There are, broadly, two options for Ethernet magnetics that are widely used today. The first is to add an Ethernet magnetics module to your design’s PCB, between the PHY chip and the connector jack. The second is to use a jack with the magnetics integrated into its housing. As you’d expect, both options have advantages and disadvantages.

Discrete Ethernet transformer modules with multiple channels in SMT packaging are widely available and usually incorporate a common mode choke on each channel for noise mitigation purposes, as 10Mbps connections and faster need this to pass FCC testing. Discrete magnetics modules are often used in cost-sensitive applications as they can be less expensive  than the integrated equivalent. They also help maximise the system’s protection from electrostatic discharge (ESD) as this design allows greater physical separation between the devices in the Ethernet front end.

The Bel Magnetics S558-5999-Q2-F is a dual channel 1000BASE-T LAN magnetics module while the M8-F (also pictured bottom left) is single channel  

 

The Ethernet standard is clear on the properties the magnetics need to have. For example, a transformer for a 100BASE-T connection is required to have an inductance value of at least 350µH when a DC bias of 8mA is applied. So all magnetics modules designed for Ethernet isolation will have this in common. 

Things to look out for when choosing a discrete magnetics module include the common mode rejection figures, which refer to the ability to reject noise picked up by the cable and/or produced by any impedance mismatches. You may also compare modules based on figures such as the insertion loss at different frequencies (effectively the loss of energy between the input and the output) and return loss at different frequencies (loss of energy due to impedance matching). 

Another consideration is crosstalk between transmit and receive channels, which should be minimised – some modules feature shielding between the channels which can provide extra protection. Consider also the likely temperatures in your application, as devices are available with different operating temperature ranges. For example, the Bel Magnetics range come in 0 to 70°C or 
-40 to +85°C versions. 

Checking the literature for the PHY chip in your design will often reveal the manufacturer’s recommendations based on specific modules they have tested alongside their own chip, so that represents a good place to start. 

Toroidal transformers

TDK has a slightly unusual take on transformers for Ethernet magnetics. The company wanted to use toroidal (doughnut-shaped) transformers in this application as they have excellent leakage flux characteristics, but since toroidal transformers have to be hand-wound, the manufacturing tolerances are typically too loose. TDK borrowed an idea it already uses for its SMD common mode choke coils – it uses machine winding to add coils to a drum core, then combines it with a flat plate core, making the toroidal shape. The result is the ALT series.

The structure of the TDK ALT series – the coils are wound by machine onto a rectangular drum core and combined with a plate core to make the desired toroidal shape

 

The ALT series offers much better uniformity compared to hand wound devices, and it can provide comparable performance to equivalent products at a much smaller footprint. These devices are used discretely alongside separate common mode chokes but can save 40 to 60% of the board space that a comparable module uses. 

Integrated Connector Modules

As an alternative to discrete magnetics modules, Ethernet connectors with all the required magnetics integrated into their housing have been available for some time. These integrated connector modules (ICMs) can offer a quicker and easier design process, lower component count, lower assembly cost and often, smaller footprints than using a separate module. Reliability is improved as there are fewer solder connections in the design. However, if the connector fails during production test, there may be a higher cost associated with reworking than with a discrete module.

The market leader for ICMs is Bel Stewart’s MagJack range, which comes in 10/100Base-T to 10GBase-T and PoE (plus) versions

 

Inside the connector housing, the cores are relatively small and close together which can result in relatively high levels of crosstalk. Most modern devices feature shielding for precisely this purpose. Other EMI considerations include keeping the PCB tracks between the PHY and the ICM as short as possible. In fact, since track lengths can be kept shorter when using an ICM compared to a discrete module, ICMs have a slight advantage here. As stated above though, these short distances can cause problems with ESD susceptibility. 

If you need help choosing between discrete and ICM Ethernet magnetics, get in touch with our technical specialists on our Ask an Expert page. 

 

 

 

 

Want more like this? Sign up for our newsletters

About Author

Adam Chidley Photo
Adam Chidley

Adam joined Avnet Abacus in 2006 as a Sales Consultant, moving into Product Management 18 months lat...

Ethernet Magnetics: Discrete Or Integrated? | Engineers' Insight | Avnet Abacus

Display portlet menu
Contact our product specialists

Ask an expert

Have a question? Our regional technical specialists are on hand to help.

Ethernet Magnetics: Discrete Or Integrated? | Engineers' Insight | Avnet Abacus

Display portlet menu
Related Articles
An electric vehicle charging cable being plugged into a charging station
An introduction to EV charging infrastructure design
February 7, 2020
With demand for faster charging of EV vehicles increasing, the design of charging stations and infrastructure becomes ever more important.
Inside of a connected car depicting
V2X: The future of vehicle communications
By Martin Keenan   -   December 10, 2019
Vehicles are about to become a lot more communicative: with other road users, with the infrastructure they pass on their journeys, with cloud-based services, and even with the energy grid. This communication should make vehicles more economical to operate...
Tesla plugged into charging station
Switching high voltages and currents with PCB-mounted relays
By Martin Keenan   -   November 8, 2019
The growing demand for safe, robust and energy-efficient ways to switch relatively large amounts of power means that relays have an important role to play in a wide range of modern applications.
Avnet Abacus helps engineers to develop smart flow meters for monitoring water and gas consumption. Alan Jermyn, VP Marketing, looks at what’s driving demand for smart meters, how they work and how they’re built.
Taking flow measurement to the next level
By Alan Jermyn   -   October 25, 2019
Avnet Abacus helps engineers to develop smart flow meters for monitoring water and gas consumption. Alan Jermyn, VP Marketing, looks at what’s driving demand for smart meters, how they work and how they’re built.
While connectors are not the most interesting components in automotive systems, they can make or break a design. Here, Mathias Goebel looks at the four main factors affecting connector choices in modern automotive applications.
4 factors steering connector choices in today's automotive applications
September 16, 2019
While connectors are not the most interesting components in automotive systems, they can make or break a design. Here, Mathias Goebel looks at the four main factors affecting connector choices in modern automotive applications.
When specifying connectors for IIoT applications, making the right choice is vital to ensuring the integrity of the transmission. Vibration, humidity and environmental stress are regular concerns when specifying any system component for a factory or
Industry 3.0 vs. Industry 4.0: Selecting connectors for the new industrial age
June 17, 2019
When specifying connectors for IIoT applications, making the right choice is vital to ensuring the integrity of the transmission. Vibration, humidity and environmental stress are regular concerns when specifying any system component for a factory or
Recent advances in wireless technology have enabled the use of mesh network topologies in home and building control applications, but what are your options, and can you combine them?
A quick guide to multi-standard mesh networking
By Alessandro Mastellari   -   April 11, 2019
Recent advances in wireless technology have enabled the use of mesh network topologies in home and building control applications, but what are your options, and can you combine them?
To mark International Women’s Day, we spoke to two female engineers at different points in their careers – one from the UK and one from Germany – to find out from them what their take is on being a woman in engineering
Women in engineering – where are we now?
By Lisa Rees   -   March 7, 2019
To mark International Women’s Day, we spoke to two female engineers at different points in their careers – one from the UK and one from Germany – to find out from them what their take is on being a woman in engineering and to learn more about t
As the world becomes increasingly smart and connected, batteries can be undesirable in some of the use cases. Kinetic energy harvesting is an alternative that can help achieve longer operating lifetimes, relieve ownership costs, and ideally improve r
A quick guide to powering smart objects with kinetic energy harvesting
By Alessandro Mastellari   -   January 22, 2019
As the world becomes increasingly smart and connected, batteries can be undesirable in some of the use cases. Kinetic energy harvesting is an alternative that can help achieve longer operating lifetimes, relieve ownership costs, and ideally improve r
Cars used to be little more than four wheels, four seats, an internal combustion engine, and enough electronics to get a spark to each plug at the right time. Today’s vehicles are radically more complex.
Design trends: Automotive passives
By Martin Keenan   -   November 29, 2018
Cars used to be little more than four wheels, four seats, an internal combustion engine, and enough electronics to get a spark to each plug at the right time. Today’s vehicles are radically more complex.
And so electronica 2018 is over. In our final post, we look back on the best bits of day three.
From humanoids to holograms and humanity projects - How Avnet showcased the future at electronica
November 16, 2018
And so electronica 2018 is over. In our final post, we look back on the best bits of day three.
Another day at electronica 2018 has passed and it was arguably even busier than the first. A constant stream of customers and suppliers kept the atmosphere on the Avnet Abacus stand buzzing, and our schedule was packed full of great speakers and demo
electronica 2018 day two highlights
November 15, 2018
Another day at electronica 2018 has passed and it was arguably even busier than the first. A constant stream of customers and suppliers kept the atmosphere on the Avnet Abacus stand buzzing, and our schedule was packed full of great speakers and demo
On a crisp morning at Messe Munich there was an excited buzz around the exhibition centre as electronica 2018 opened its doors. Read what happened on day one.
electronica 2018 day one highlights
November 13, 2018
On a crisp morning at Messe Munich there was an excited buzz around the exhibition centre as electronica 2018 opened its doors. Read what happened on day one.
As electronica 2018 prepares to open its doors, here are three reasons you should visit Avnet Abacus on stand C5 101 this week.
3 reasons to visit Avnet Abacus at electronica 2018
November 12, 2018
As electronica 2018 prepares to open its doors, here are three reasons you should visit Avnet Abacus on stand C5 101 this week.
Traditional battery technologies are being challenged by a relatively new kid on the block, the supercapacitor, and forcing developers across a range of battery-powered applications to examine just what and when power is needed for their system.
A supercapacitor in every system? Potential is turning to probability
By Ekaterina Rachel   -   August 24, 2018
Traditional battery technologies are being challenged by a relatively new kid on the block, the supercapacitor, and forcing developers across a range of battery-powered applications to examine just what and when power is needed for their system.
Thermal runaway can happen as a direct result of component failure and cause a lot of damage, but there are ways to protect against it.
Identifying ‘hot spots’ before they cause thermal runaway
By Juliette Whithair   -   August 16, 2018
Thermal runaway can happen as a direct result of component failure and cause a lot of damage, but there are ways to protect against it.
When faced with the need to make design decisions, system engineers are challenged with multiple options, any of which can have a major impact on the effectiveness of the wireless performance.There are many considerations when selecting RF antennas f
Key design considerations for selecting the right RF antenna
August 7, 2018
When faced with the need to make design decisions, system engineers are challenged with multiple options, any of which can have a major impact on the effectiveness of the wireless performance.There are many considerations when selecting RF antennas f
An ICM, or integrated connector module is a type of connector that integrates all the magnetics required to meet the Ethernet standard for xBASE-T connections. They provide a quick and easy solution for Ethernet connectivity, but how do you know whic
Selecting an Ethernet ICM the easy way
By Marco Enge   -   July 25, 2018
An ICM, or integrated connector module is a type of connector that integrates all the magnetics required to meet the Ethernet standard for xBASE-T connections. They provide a quick and easy solution for Ethernet connectivity, but how do you know whic
The new era of home security won’t just be an alarm that rings when a lock is picked or a window broken. With the rise of new technology comes the added need to protect a home’s hardware and its software.
Security and surveillance: Two sides of the coin in smart homes
By Martin Keenan   -   July 9, 2018
The new era of home security won’t just be an alarm that rings when a lock is picked or a window broken. With the rise of new technology comes the added need to protect a home’s hardware and its software.
You've selected your wireless protocol, and you're ready to start designing. But should you take the modular route or build a discrete solution?
Wireless modules point the way for IoT connectivity
By Martin Keenan   -   June 26, 2018
You've selected your wireless protocol, and you're ready to start designing. But should you take the modular route or build a discrete solution?
The lighting industry is not short of options for digital connectivity, but what it needs is a standard that adapts itself to change. Enter Bluetooth 5.
Future proofing lighting systems with Bluetooth
By Alessandro Mastellari   -   May 9, 2018
The lighting industry is not short of options for digital connectivity, but what it needs is a standard that adapts itself to change. Enter Bluetooth 5.
Wireless technology is endemic in modern society; broadly speaking we rely on cellular technology to stay connected when we’re travelling, and probably WiFi when we’re not.
Choosing the right wireless technology for your IoT end-device
By Adam Chidley   -   May 4, 2018
Wireless communications will connect the IoT, but it’s not quite as straightforward as adding a Wi-Fi access point to your home broadband. Avnet Abacus’ Adam Chidley takes a look at low power WANs and why they will be essential in connecting thin
The role of the battery in product design has become increasingly important. In fact, you could say it has provoked a change in design methodology, albeit with a bit of help from legislative bodies.
Optimising battery designs with supercapacitors
By Tim Parker   -   April 30, 2018
The role of the battery in product design has become increasingly important. In fact, you could say it has provoked a change in design methodology, albeit with a bit of help from legislative bodies.
Man controlling home devices via his watch
Let your home do the work so you don't have to
By Martin Keenan   -   March 29, 2018
Today, we need to interact with connected products in the home deliberately. But it does not have to stay this way.
Numbers of EV charging points are set to increase dramatically under a draft EU directive expected to come into effect in 2019, but the design challenges for EV charging solutions are many and varied.
EV charging points set to rapidly increase in numbers
By Marco Enge   -   January 18, 2018
Numbers of EV charging points are set to increase dramatically under a draft EU directive expected to come into effect in 2019, but the design challenges for EV charging solutions are many and varied.
Electronics used in outdoor locations have to contend with harsh weather conditions, including direct sunlight, rain, ice, and even earthquakes. But that’s not the whole story.
Protecting outdoor electronics against vandals
By Jerry Moss   -   December 18, 2017
Electronics used in outdoor locations have to contend with harsh weather conditions, including direct sunlight, rain, ice, and even earthquakes. But that’s not the whole story.
Connector manufacturers are working hard to enhance the performance of rugged connectors, writes Martin Keenan, Avnet Abacus
Balancing performance, speed and cost for rugged interconnect technologies
By Martin Keenan   -   November 2, 2017
Connector manufacturers are working hard to enhance the performance of rugged connectors, writes Martin Keenan, Avnet Abacus
RF When considering the exponential growth of transferred data, most headlines are captured by wireless innovation, but advances continue to be made in the wired domain, not least in RF connectors.
Advances and trends in RF connection
By Marco Enge   -   October 19, 2017
When considering the exponential growth of transferred data, most headlines are captured by wireless innovation, but advances continue to be made in the wired domain, not least in RF connectors.
Do you know where your product has been and where it is going right now? This is the challenge that many manufacturers and logistics companies face in the management of their supply chains, but how can RFID technology solve it?
Enabling smart tracking for the supply chain and Industry 4.0 with RFID
By Adam Chidley   -   September 27, 2017
Do you know where your product has been and where it is going right now? This is the challenge that many manufacturers and logistics companies face in the management of their supply chains, but how can RFID technology solve it?
As pressure on the world’s lithium reserves increases, wireless power transfer simplifies charging and enables designers to use lower-capacity batteries and create new types of smart devices.
How wireless power transfer can help make the world’s lithium go further
By Martin Keenan   -   September 19, 2017
As pressure on the world’s lithium reserves increases, wireless power transfer simplifies charging and enables designers to use lower-capacity batteries and create new types of smart devices.
As the intelligence of vehicle electronic systems increases, wireless connectivity is becoming an important feature, enabling passenger communications and cloud connectivity for advanced features instances of emergency such as eCall.
Automotive telematics become mandatory with eCall
By Alan Jermyn   -   August 1, 2017
As the intelligence of vehicle electronic systems increases, wireless connectivity is becoming an important feature, enabling passenger communications and cloud connectivity for advanced features instances of emergency such as eCall.
In an increasingly connected world, performance demands on antennas are greater than ever. These increased performance demands also have to be balanced with cost, and of course, the limits imposed by the laws of physics, which make antenna design a t
Customising and optimising antennas with materials science and manufacturing techniques
By Martin Keenan   -   July 14, 2017
In an increasingly connected world, performance demands on antennas are greater than ever. These increased performance demands also have to be balanced with cost, and of course, the limits imposed by the laws of physics, which make antenna design a t
Specialised enclosures and switches are required for electronics’ survival in the great outdoors, writes Jerry Moss, Avnet Abacus.
Weather, corrosion and vandals: Protecting outdoor electronics
By Jerry Moss   -   June 30, 2017
Specialised enclosures and switches are required for electronics’ survival in the great outdoors, writes Jerry Moss, Avnet Abacus.
Most modern power conversion topologies use switched-mode techniques for highest efficiency and smallest size and cost.
Keeping the noise down: Converter and inverter output filtering
By Adam Chidley   -   May 31, 2017
Most modern power conversion topologies use switched-mode techniques for highest efficiency and smallest size and cost. Inevitably, switching noise is produced and output filters are required to minimise EMI and provide reliable operation of the powe
‘DC-link’ capacitors feature in many power conversion topologies and must be chosen carefully to give the best trade-off between cost, size and performance.
Selecting DC-link capacitors in power converters
By Adam Chidley   -   May 10, 2017
‘DC-link’ capacitors feature in many power conversion topologies and must be chosen carefully to give the best trade-off between cost, size and performance.
Inverters and converters have become basic building blocks for many modern power applications. These applications must meet statutory and practical requirements for input EMI filtering and protection against injury to personnel and equipment
Input filtering and protection for switched mode inverters and converters
By Adam Chidley   -   April 25, 2017
Inverters and converters have become basic building blocks for many modern power applications. These applications must meet statutory and practical requirements for input EMI filtering and protection against injury to personnel and equipment
Datacentre racks
Chip-to-chip at the speed of light
By Marco Enge   -   March 31, 2017
As data centres and data farms continue to expand and grow, better solutions are required for system architectures that allow faster communication and more efficient operation.
The threat of explosion is real in many of today’s industrial applications, and connectors are critical to explosion proofing since they have the potential to create arcs and sparks as part of normal operation.
Specifying explosion-proof connectors
By Marco Enge   -   March 30, 2017
The threat of explosion is real in many of today’s industrial applications, and connectors are critical to explosion proofing since they have the potential to create arcs and sparks as part of normal operation.
Supercapacitors are commonly used as an alternative to a rechargeable battery wherever a quick energy boost is needed, however there is another type of device on the market which combines the best features of EDLCs and Li-ion batteries.
Hybrid capacitors combine technologies to get the best of both worlds
By Martin Keenan   -   March 15, 2017
Supercapacitors are commonly used as an alternative to a rechargeable battery wherever a quick energy boost is needed, however there is another type of device on the market which combines the best features of EDLCs and Li-ion batteries.
Adam Chidley explains how component diversity has made selecting the best capacitors for power-related applications more complex than ever, and why taking independent advice makes sense.
Understanding ESR in electrolytic capacitors
By Adam Chidley   -   March 1, 2017
Adam Chidley explains how component diversity has made selecting the best capacitors for power-related applications more complex than ever, and why taking independent advice makes sense.
Selecting the right cable and/or connector assembly for a fibre optic installation need not be complex, but it is important to understand the requirements of the environment and the application.
Selecting fibre optic cables
By Marco Enge   -   July 12, 2016
Selecting the right cable and/or connector assembly for a fibre optic installation need not be complex, but it is important to understand the requirements of the environment and the application.
Industry 4.0 and the digitisation of the manufacturing sector will have repercussions for all sectors of industrial electronics.
Evolving component technologies will make Industry 4.0 viable
By Martin Keenan   -   May 22, 2016
Industry 4.0 and the digitisation of the manufacturing sector will have repercussions for all sectors of industrial electronics.
Thermal management is of critical importance in LED lighting systems. LEDs themselves give off heat when lit due to their own inefficiencies, and knock on effects of that heat can rapidly reduce the LEDs’ lifespan if it isn’t managed carefully.
Calculating LED heatsinks
By Giovanna Monari   -   May 22, 2016
Thermal management is of critical importance in LED lighting systems. LEDs themselves give off heat when lit due to their own inefficiencies, and knock on effects of that heat can rapidly reduce the LEDs’ lifespan if it isn’t managed carefully.
Aluminium electrolytic and polymer wound aluminium electrolytic capacitors may seem similar at first glance, but the technologies offer very different performance characteristics.
‘Wet’ aluminium and polymer aluminium capacitors – what’s the difference?
By Ekaterina Rachel   -   April 1, 2016
Aluminium electrolytic and polymer wound aluminium electrolytic capacitors may seem similar at first glance, but the technologies offer very different performance characteristics.
Although they’ve been superseded in some applications by newer technologies such as solid state relays (SSRs), electromechanical relays (EMRs) still have a lot to offer.
Modern electromechanical relays meet today’s reliability demands
By Giovanna Monari   -   February 2, 2016
Although they’ve been superseded in some applications by newer technologies such as solid state relays (SSRs), electromechanical relays (EMRs) still have a lot to offer.
LEDs are widely touted as the perfect solution for lighting applications because, in theory at least, they last forever.What’s less frequently spoken about is that circuit protection can make or break the design.
Circuit protection is vital for long lifetimes in LED lighting
By Adam Chidley   -   January 7, 2016
LEDs are widely touted as the perfect solution for lighting applications because, in theory at least, they last forever.What’s less frequently spoken about is that circuit protection can make or break the design.
Today, supercapacitors are widely used in transport applications to help stabilise the output power of a main power source and improve fuel efficiency.
Supercapacitors: Making transport more efficient
By Adam Chidley   -   September 7, 2015
Today, supercapacitors are widely used in transport applications to help stabilise the output power of a main power source and improve fuel efficiency.
The various types of capacitors all have their advantages and disadvantages, but polymer capacitors offer a host of desirable electrical characteristics.
The unstoppable rise of polymer capacitors
By Ekaterina Rachel   -   August 10, 2015
The various types of capacitors all have their advantages and disadvantages, but polymer capacitors offer a host of desirable electrical characteristics.
The invention of the micro switch goes back over 80 years to 1932 and is attributed to one Peter McGall of Freeport, Illinois, USA. Who knows how many billion of these handy little components have been manufactured since, but there can hardly be a ho
Understanding micro switches and hysteresis
By Giovanna Monari   -   June 12, 2015
The invention of the micro switch goes back over 80 years to 1932 and is attributed to one Peter McGall of Freeport, Illinois, USA. Who knows how many billion of these handy little components have been manufactured since, but there can hardly be a ho
Fans are often looked at like insurance policies – they’re something you need, rather than something you want.
Fans have few fans, but perhaps they should?
By Mathias Goebel   -   May 28, 2015
Fans are often looked at like insurance policies – they’re something you need, rather than something you want.
Supercapacitors are an alternative to using a battery or indeed the more common-or-garden variety of capacitor in many energy storage applications, perhaps as backup power or for high-surge demand applications.
What’s super about supercapacitors?
By Adam Chidley   -   May 18, 2015
Supercapacitors are an alternative to using a battery or indeed the more common-or-garden variety of capacitor in many energy storage applications, perhaps as backup power or for high-surge demand applications.
Machine-to-machine (M2M) communications has undergone phenomenal growth in recent years and connectivity is becoming increasingly reliant upon wireless networks.
Latest developments in antennas for M2M communications
By Marco Enge   -   April 30, 2015
Machine-to-machine (M2M) communications has undergone phenomenal growth in recent years and connectivity is becoming increasingly reliant upon wireless networks.
Thermal management is a key element of LED lighting design, ensuring reliable operation, better performance and extended device lifetimes.
LED thermal management: Is it just me or is it getting hot in here?
By Giovanna Monari   -   March 19, 2015
Thermal management is a key element of LED lighting design, ensuring reliable operation, better performance and extended device lifetimes.

Ethernet Magnetics: Discrete Or Integrated? | Engineers' Insight | Avnet Abacus

Display portlet menu
Related Events
Embedded World 2020
Date: February 25, 2020
Location: Nuremburg, Germany